professional/wow-inequalities
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

feat: Update search query for new protocol

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
Marty Oehme 2023-10-23 10:35:25 +02:00
parent a702bbd42f
commit f6f0e087cd
Signed by: Marty
GPG key ID: EDBF2ED917B2EF6A
2 changed files with 281 additions and 171 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

221
notes.md
View file

@ -830,106 +830,159 @@ TS=
( (
( (
work OR work OR
labor labour OR
) AND
(
production of goods OR production of goods OR
provision of services OR provision of services OR
use by others OR
own-use OR own-use OR
use by others OR
of working age OR
for pay OR for pay OR
for profit OR for profit OR
remunerated OR remuneration OR
for wages OR market transactions
waged OR ) AND
for salaries OR (
salaried OR (
for time worked OR own-use OR
for work done OR employment OR
profits derived OR unpaid trainee OR
through market transactions volunteer OR
other work activities OR
wage-employed OR
self-employed OR
formal work OR
informal work OR
domestic work OR
care work OR
unpaid work
) OR
(
employment outcomes OR
labour rights OR
equality of oppoertunity OR
equality of outcome OR
labour force participationOR
labour force exit OR
job quality OR
career advancement OR
hours worked OR
wage OR
salary OR
return to work
)
) )
) AND ) AND
TS= TS=
( (
employment OR (
unpaid trainee OR intervention OR
volunteer OR policy OR
domestic work OR participation OR
wage-employed OR targeting/targeted OR
self-employed OR distributive OR
formal employment OR redistributive
informal employment OR )
unpaid care work OR AND
care work (
) AND (
support for childcare OR
TS=( labour rights OR
intervention OR minimum wage OR
policy OR collective bargaining OR
policies OR business sustainability promotion OR
participation OR work-life balance promotion OR
targeting OR equal pay for work of equal value OR
targeted removal of (discriminatory) law OR
law reformation OR
guaranteed income OR
universal basic income OR
provision of living wage OR
maternity leave
)
OR
(
cash benefits OR
services in kind OR
green transition OR
infrastructure OR
digital infrastructure OR
quality of education OR
public service improvement OR
lowering of gender segregation OR
price stability intervention OR
extended social protection scheme OR
comprehensive social protection OR
sustainable social protection OR
supported employment OR
vocational rehabilitation
)
OR
(
credit programs OR
career guidance OR
vocational guidance OR
vocational counselling OR
counteracting of stereotypes OR
commuting subsidies OR
housing mobility programs OR
encouraging re-situation/migration OR
encouraging self-advocacy OR
cognitive behavioural therapy OR
computer-assisted therapy OR
work organization OR
special transportation
)
)
) AND ) AND
TS= TS=
( (
inequality OR
inequalities OR
barriers OR
advantaged OR
disadvantaged OR
discriminated OR
disparity OR
disparities
) AND
TS=
(
income OR
identity OR
gender OR
beliefs OR
color OR
racial OR
ethnic OR
ethnicity OR
migrant OR
nationality OR
spatial AND
( (
rural OR inequality OR
urban OR inequalities OR
mega-city OR barriers OR
large city OR advantaged OR
small city OR disadvantaged OR
peripheral city discriminated OR
) OR disparity OR
age AND disparities
)
AND
( (
young OR (
youth OR income OR
old OR Palma ratio OR
senior Gini coefficient OR
) OR class OR
disability OR fertility OR
health status OR bottom percentile OR
education OR top percentile
educational access OR )
social mobility OR
) AND (
identity OR
TS=( demographic OR
employment outcome OR gender OR
labor rights OR colour OR
opportunities between groups OR beliefs OR
equality of opportunity OR racial OR
equality of outcome OR ethnic OR
labour market outcome OR migrant OR
income OR spatial OR
job quality rural OR
urban OR
mega-cities OR
small cities OR
peripheral cities OR
age OR
nationality OR
ethnicity OR
health status OR
disability OR
characteristics
)
)
) )
``` ```

231
scoping_review.qmd
View file

@ -261,7 +261,7 @@ Understanding such channels becomes difficult if not taking pre-existing inequal
Addressing these inequalities, in turn, is just as important to reducing inequalities within the labour market (as well as beyond) since they do play such a role for intergenerational social mobility and their impacts can be seen, once again, reflecting in the prism of subsequent income inequality. Addressing these inequalities, in turn, is just as important to reducing inequalities within the labour market (as well as beyond) since they do play such a role for intergenerational social mobility and their impacts can be seen, once again, reflecting in the prism of subsequent income inequality.
For pre-existing inequalities, it will be especially important to understand the often delayed and more opaque nature of the roots of many outcomes, with channel being more difficult to identify and clearly label – especially in an intersectional context. For pre-existing inequalities, it will be especially important to understand the often delayed and more opaque nature of the roots of many outcomes, with channel being more difficult to identify and clearly label – especially in an intersectional context.
# Scoping Review methodology # The search protocol
This section will discuss the systematic scoping review methodology that is proposed to conduct the review of the literature on policy interventions that are expected to address inequalities in forms of work and labour market outcomes. This section will discuss the systematic scoping review methodology that is proposed to conduct the review of the literature on policy interventions that are expected to address inequalities in forms of work and labour market outcomes.
Unlike purely systematic reviews which typically focus on specific policy questions and interventions, systematic scoping reviews focus on a wider spectrum of policies, where different study designs and research questions can be investigated. Unlike purely systematic reviews which typically focus on specific policy questions and interventions, systematic scoping reviews focus on a wider spectrum of policies, where different study designs and research questions can be investigated.
@ -298,7 +298,7 @@ Relevant results are then complemented through the adoption of a 'snowballing' t
To identify potential studies and create an initial sample, relevant terms for the clusters of world of work, inequality and policy interventions have been extracted from the existing reviews as well as the ILO definitions. To identify potential studies and create an initial sample, relevant terms for the clusters of world of work, inequality and policy interventions have been extracted from the existing reviews as well as the ILO definitions.
Identified terms comprising the world of work can be found in @tbl-wow-terms, Identified terms comprising the world of work can be found in @tbl-wow-terms,
with the search query requiring a term from each column. with the search query requiring a term from the general column and one other column.
```{python} ```{python}
#| label: tbl-wow-terms #| label: tbl-wow-terms
@ -334,7 +334,7 @@ wow_terms_cluster = {
"Labour market outcomes": pd.Series([ "Labour market outcomes": pd.Series([
"employment outcomes", "employment outcomes",
"labour rights", "labour rights",
"equality of oppoertunity", "equality of opportunity",
"equality of outcome", "equality of outcome",
"labour force participation [@Pinto2021]", "labour force participation [@Pinto2021]",
"labour force exit [@Silvaggi2020]", "labour force exit [@Silvaggi2020]",
@ -516,6 +516,10 @@ Similarly, if a specific type of inequality, or a specific intervention, represe
The complete process of identification and screening is undertaken with the help of the Zotero reference manager, ultimately leaving only publications which are relevant for final full-text review and analysis. The complete process of identification and screening is undertaken with the help of the Zotero reference manager, ultimately leaving only publications which are relevant for final full-text review and analysis.
Last, for extraction, studies are screened for their full-texts, irrelevant studies excluded with ‘excluded::full-text’ as explained above and relevant studies then ingested into the final sample pool. Last, for extraction, studies are screened for their full-texts, irrelevant studies excluded with ‘excluded::full-text’ as explained above and relevant studies then ingested into the final sample pool.
Should any literature reviews be identified as relevant during this screening process,
they will in turn be crawled for cited sources in a 'snowballing' process,
and the sources will be added to the sample to undergo the same screening process explained above.
All relevant data concerning both their major findings and statistical significance are then extracted from the individual studies into a collective results matrix. All relevant data concerning both their major findings and statistical significance are then extracted from the individual studies into a collective results matrix.
The results to be identified in the matrix include a study’s: i) key outcome measures (dependent variables), ii) main findings, iii) main policy interventions (independent variables), iv) study design and sample size, v) dataset and methods of evaluation, vi) direction of relation and level of representativeness, vii) level of statistical significance, viii) main limitations. The results to be identified in the matrix include a study’s: i) key outcome measures (dependent variables), ii) main findings, iii) main policy interventions (independent variables), iv) study design and sample size, v) dataset and methods of evaluation, vi) direction of relation and level of representativeness, vii) level of statistical significance, viii) main limitations.
@ -559,106 +563,159 @@ TS=
( (
( (
work OR work OR
labor labour OR
) AND
(
production of goods OR production of goods OR
provision of services OR provision of services OR
use by others OR
own-use OR own-use OR
use by others OR
of working age OR
for pay OR for pay OR
for profit OR for profit OR
remunerated OR remuneration OR
for wages OR market transactions
waged OR ) AND
for salaries OR (
salaried OR (
for time worked OR own-use OR
for work done OR employment OR
profits derived OR unpaid trainee OR
through market transactions volunteer OR
other work activities OR
wage-employed OR
self-employed OR
formal work OR
informal work OR
domestic work OR
care work OR
unpaid work
) OR
(
employment outcomes OR
labour rights OR
equality of opportunity OR
equality of outcome OR
labour force participationOR
labour force exit OR
job quality OR
career advancement OR
hours worked OR
wage OR
salary OR
return to work
)
) )
) AND ) AND
TS= TS=
( (
employment OR (
unpaid trainee OR intervention OR
volunteer OR policy OR
domestic work OR participation OR
wage-employed OR targeting/targeted OR
self-employed OR distributive OR
formal employment OR redistributive
informal employment OR )
unpaid care work OR AND
care work (
) AND (
support for childcare OR
TS=( labour rights OR
intervention OR minimum wage OR
policy OR collective bargaining OR
policies OR business sustainability promotion OR
participation OR work-life balance promotion OR
targeting OR equal pay for work of equal value OR
targeted removal of (discriminatory) law OR
law reformation OR
guaranteed income OR
universal basic income OR
provision of living wage OR
maternity leave
)
OR
(
cash benefits OR
services in kind OR
green transition OR
infrastructure OR
digital infrastructure OR
quality of education OR
public service improvement OR
lowering of gender segregation OR
price stability intervention OR
extended social protection scheme OR
comprehensive social protection OR
sustainable social protection OR
supported employment OR
vocational rehabilitation
)
OR
(
credit programs OR
career guidance OR
vocational guidance OR
vocational counselling OR
counteracting of stereotypes OR
commuting subsidies OR
housing mobility programs OR
encouraging re-situation/migration OR
encouraging self-advocacy OR
cognitive behavioural therapy OR
computer-assisted therapy OR
work organization OR
special transportation
)
)
) AND ) AND
TS= TS=
( (
inequality OR
inequalities OR
barriers OR
advantaged OR
disadvantaged OR
discriminated OR
disparity OR
disparities
) AND
TS=
(
income OR
identity OR
gender OR
beliefs OR
color OR
racial OR
ethnic OR
ethnicity OR
migrant OR
nationality OR
spatial AND
( (
rural OR inequality OR
urban OR inequalities OR
mega-city OR barriers OR
large city OR advantaged OR
small city OR disadvantaged OR
peripheral city discriminated OR
) OR disparity OR
age AND disparities
)
AND
( (
young OR (
youth OR income OR
old OR Palma ratio OR
senior Gini coefficient OR
) OR class OR
disability OR fertility OR
health status OR bottom percentile OR
education OR top percentile
educational access OR )
social mobility OR
) AND (
identity OR
TS=( demographic OR
employment outcome OR gender OR
labor rights OR colour OR
opportunities between groups OR beliefs OR
equality of opportunity OR racial OR
equality of outcome OR ethnic OR
labour market outcome OR migrant OR
income OR spatial OR
job quality rural OR
urban OR
mega-cities OR
small cities OR
peripheral cities OR
age OR
nationality OR
ethnicity OR
health status OR
disability OR
characteristics
)
)
) )
``` ```