professional/wow-inequalities
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity

feat(script): Add source note to exclusion term table

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
Marty Oehme 2024-02-17 16:15:54 +01:00
parent 86610803d4
commit 71d02ff8dd
Signed by: Marty
GPG key ID: EDBF2ED917B2EF6A
1 changed files with 26 additions and 5 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

31
scoping_review.qmd
View file

@ -151,6 +151,8 @@ The ILO has a policy approach to reducing inequalities in the world of work segm
Each of these areas in turn rests on a variety of more specific emphases which further describe the potential implemented policy measures. Each of these areas in turn rests on a variety of more specific emphases which further describe the potential implemented policy measures.
An exemplary typology of general policy area, related specified policy focus and related focus if any can be found in @tbl-policy-areas. An exemplary typology of general policy area, related specified policy focus and related focus if any can be found in @tbl-policy-areas.
::: {#tbl-policy-areas}
| area of policy | focus | related | | area of policy | focus | related |
|-------------------------:|----------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------| |-------------------------:|----------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------|
| employment creation | pro-employment framework | | | employment creation | pro-employment framework | |
@ -189,10 +191,12 @@ An exemplary typology of general policy area, related specified policy focus and
| | | adequate social protection | | | | adequate social protection |
| | | sustainable social protection | | | | sustainable social protection |
: ILO focus areas for inequality reduction {#tbl-policy-areas}
Source: Authors' elaboration based on ILO [-@ILO2022b]. Source: Authors' elaboration based on ILO [-@ILO2022b].
ILO focus areas for inequality reduction
:::
## Inequalities in the world of work ## Inequalities in the world of work
Inequalities in the world of work have to be fundamentally conceptualized along two axes: On the one hand, vertical inequality captures the "income inequality between all households in a country" [@ILO2021]. Inequalities in the world of work have to be fundamentally conceptualized along two axes: On the one hand, vertical inequality captures the "income inequality between all households in a country" [@ILO2021].
@ -364,13 +368,18 @@ To identify potential studies and create an initial sample, relevant terms for t
Identified terms comprising the world of work can be found in @tbl-wow-terms, Identified terms comprising the world of work can be found in @tbl-wow-terms,
with the search query requiring a term from the general column and one other column. with the search query requiring a term from the general column and one other column.
::: {#tbl-wow-terms}
```{python} ```{python}
#| label: tbl-wow-terms #| label: tbl-wow-terms
#| tbl-cap: World of work term cluster
terms_wow = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/terms_wow.csv") terms_wow = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/terms_wow.csv")
md(tabulate(terms_wow.fillna(""), showindex=False, headers="keys", tablefmt="grid")) md(tabulate(terms_wow.fillna(""), showindex=False, headers="keys", tablefmt="grid"))
``` ```
World of work term cluster
:::
The world of work cluster, like the inequality and policy intervention clusters below, is made up of a general signifier (such as "work", "inequality" or "intervention") which has to be labelled in a study to form part of the sample, The world of work cluster, like the inequality and policy intervention clusters below, is made up of a general signifier (such as "work", "inequality" or "intervention") which has to be labelled in a study to form part of the sample,
as well as any additional terms looking into one or multiple specific dimensions or categories of these signifiers (such as "domestic" work, "gender" inequality, "maternity leave" intervention). as well as any additional terms looking into one or multiple specific dimensions or categories of these signifiers (such as "domestic" work, "gender" inequality, "maternity leave" intervention).
At least one general term and at least one additional term have to be mentioned by a study to be identified for the initial sample pool. At least one general term and at least one additional term have to be mentioned by a study to be identified for the initial sample pool.
@ -380,15 +389,20 @@ Where terms have been identified from previous reviews outside the introduced IL
there source has been included in the table. there source has been included in the table.
For the database query, a single term from the general category is required to be included in addition to one term from *any* of the remaining categories. For the database query, a single term from the general category is required to be included in addition to one term from *any* of the remaining categories.
::: {#tbl-intervention-terms}
```{python} ```{python}
#| label: tbl-intervention-terms #| label: tbl-intervention-terms
#| tbl-cap: Policy intervention term cluster
terms_policy = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/terms_policy.csv") terms_policy = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/terms_policy.csv")
# different headers to include 'social norms' # different headers to include 'social norms'
headers = ["General", "Institutional", "Structural", "Agency & social norms"] headers = ["General", "Institutional", "Structural", "Agency & social norms"]
md(tabulate(terms_policy.fillna(""), showindex=False, headers=headers, tablefmt="grid")) md(tabulate(terms_policy.fillna(""), showindex=False, headers=headers, tablefmt="grid"))
``` ```
Policy intervention term cluster
:::
Lastly, the inequality cluster is once again made up of a general term describing inequality which has to form part of the query results, as well as at least one term describing a specific vertical or horizontal inequality, Lastly, the inequality cluster is once again made up of a general term describing inequality which has to form part of the query results, as well as at least one term describing a specific vertical or horizontal inequality,
as seen in @tbl-inequality-terms. as seen in @tbl-inequality-terms.
@ -414,14 +428,21 @@ An overview of the respective criteria used for inclusion or exclusion can be fo
It restricts studies to those that comprise primary research published after 2000, It restricts studies to those that comprise primary research published after 2000,
with a focus on the narrowing criteria specified in @tbl-inclusion-criteria. with a focus on the narrowing criteria specified in @tbl-inclusion-criteria.
::: {#tbl-inclusion-criteria}
```{python} ```{python}
#| label: tbl-inclusion-criteria #| label: tbl-inclusion-criteria
#| tbl-cap: Study inclusion and exclusion scoping criteria {#tbl-inclusion-criteria}
inclusion_criteria = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/inclusion-criteria.tsv", sep="\t") inclusion_criteria = pd.read_csv("02-data/supplementary/inclusion-criteria.tsv", sep="\t")
md(tabulate(inclusion_criteria, showindex=False, headers="keys", tablefmt="grid")) md(tabulate(inclusion_criteria, showindex=False, headers="keys", tablefmt="grid"))
``` ```
Source: Author's elaboration
Study inclusion and exclusion scoping criteria
:::
To facilitate the screening process, with the help of 'Zotero' reference manager a system of keywords is used to tag individual studies in the sample with their reason for exclusion,such as ‘excluded::language’, ‘excluded::title’, ‘excluded::abstract’, and ‘excluded::superseded’. To facilitate the screening process, with the help of 'Zotero' reference manager a system of keywords is used to tag individual studies in the sample with their reason for exclusion,such as ‘excluded::language’, ‘excluded::title’, ‘excluded::abstract’, and ‘excluded::superseded’.
This keyword-based system is equally used to further categorize the sample studies that do not fall into exclusion criteria, based on primary country of analysis, world region, as well as income level classification. This keyword-based system is equally used to further categorize the sample studies that do not fall into exclusion criteria, based on primary country of analysis, world region, as well as income level classification.
To that end, a ‘country::’, ‘region::’ and ‘income::’ are used to disambiguate between the respective characteristics, such as ‘region::LAC’ for Latin America and the Caribbean, ‘region::SSA’ for Sub-Saharan Africa; as well as for example ‘income::low-middle’, ‘income::upper-middle’ or ‘income::high’. To that end, a ‘country::’, ‘region::’ and ‘income::’ are used to disambiguate between the respective characteristics, such as ‘region::LAC’ for Latin America and the Caribbean, ‘region::SSA’ for Sub-Saharan Africa; as well as for example ‘income::low-middle’, ‘income::upper-middle’ or ‘income::high’.