wow-inequalities/docs/screening-tool.md

270 lines
6.3 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Normal View History

# Scoping tool
- after identification a large pool of potential studies will be in the zotero index (usually > 1000)
- to make scoping (somewhat) rapid, we employ multi-step exclusions
- rapid scoping reviews sometimes only make use of single steps, e.g. only title-screening, as inclusion criteria
- title screening
- exclude all studies that do not match with `out::title`
- move all studies that do match into next step with `TODO::abstract`
- abstract screening
- exclude all studies that do not match with `out::abstract`
- move all studies that do match into next step with `TODO::full-text`
- studies which seem reasonably sure to be of vale can be tagged with `relevant` to be easier to spot later on
- fulltext screening
- exclude all studies that do not match with `out::full-text`
- move all studies that do match into next step with `TODO::extract`
- for any of the above steps:
- if the study is a potentially relevant review, mark with `TODO::review` for later snowballing
- if you are unsure and require outside input mark with `TODO::QUESTION`
- extraction
- mark successful extraction with `done::extracted`
- often done as full-text screening and extraction in single step
- add any relevant tags, but at least `type::`, `inequality::`, `country::` and possibly `region::` tags
# Category reference
Tracks the categories and possible values of tags (or 'keywords') for the screening process step of scoping.
## TODO
A work-in-progress tag which simply states the step of the scoping review
process the respective source is currently at.
- TODO::QUESTION
- TODO::SPANISH
- TODO::abstract
- TODO::full-text
- TODO::review
- TODO::title
- done::extracted
- done::preliminary
## Cite
Even if a study is not directly relevant for the final extraction pool,
it might contain valuable information. These tags give the reason they may
prove interesting yet when considering the inequalities analyzed by them.
- cite::channels
- cite::framework
- cite::further_reading
## Country
The main country of interest for the study. Multiple possible for comparative/multiple case studies.
Global studies, or ones using dozens of countries will not be tagged.
- country::Argentina
- country::Armenia
- country::Australia
- country::Austria
- country::Bangladesh
- country::Belgium
- country::Bengal
- country::Bolivia
- country::Bosnia_Herzegovina
- country::Botswana
- country::Brazil
- country::Britain
- country::Burundi
- country::Cambodia
- country::Cameroon
- country::Canada
- country::Chile
- country::China
- country::Colombia
- country::Croatia
- country::Cyprus
- country::Czech_Republic
- country::Denmark
- country::Ecuador
- country::Eswatini
- country::Ethiopia
- country::Finland
- country::France
- country::Germany
- country::Ghana
- country::Greece
- country::Guatemala
- country::Honduras
- country::HongKong
- country::Hungary
- country::India
- country::Indonesia
- country::Iran
- country::Ireland
- country::Israel
- country::Italy
- country::Japan
- country::Jordan
- country::Kazakhstan
- country::Kenya
- country::Korea
- country::Liberia
- country::Lithuania
- country::Madagascar
- country::Malawi
- country::Malawy
- country::Malaysia
- country::Malta
- country::Mexico
- country::Mongolia
- country::Morocco
- country::Nepal
- country::Netherlands
- country::New_Zealand
- country::Nicaragua
- country::Nigeria
- country::Norway
- country::Pakistan
- country::Paraguay
- country::Philippines
- country::Poland
- country::Portugal
- country::Romania
- country::Russia
- country::Rwanda
- country::Saudi_Arabia
- country::Senegal
- country::Slovakia
- country::South_Africa
- country::Spain
- country::Sri_Lanka
- country::Sweden
- country::Switzerland
- country::Taiwan
- country::Tanzania
- country::Thailand
- country::Timor-Leste
- country::Turkey
- country::US
- country::Ukraine
- country::Uruguay
- country::Vietnam
- country::West_Bank
- country::Zambia
## Inequality
The type of inequality illuminated by a study.
Will often be multiple, a strong sign for a study's intersectional approach.
- inequality::age
- inequality::consumption
- inequality::disability
- inequality::education
- inequality::ethnicity
- inequality::gender
- inequality::generational
- inequality::health
- inequality::income
- inequality::language
- inequality::lgbt
- inequality::migration
- inequality::poverty
- inequality::racial
- inequality::socio-demographic
- inequality::spatial
## Issue
If there is an issue with a study which may impede further
progress, or any progress at all - even if it may not be sorted
out from relevance yet, or if it has.
- issue::age
- issue::language
- issue::no-access
## Method
If one method is clearly marked as primary, or surprisingly is not
the primary method within title and or abstract, it will be noted
here.
- method::qualitative
- method::quantitative
## Out
The reason, or step of the screening process for the study falling
out of relevance. Will be used later to generate accurate numbers
per screening step.
- out::abstract
- out::full-text
- out::language
- out::review
- out::title
- out::year
## Region
The general world region a study is working in.
May align to the individual country (or countries) it is analyzing,
but may also stand on its own.
- region::global
- region::AP
- region::EU
- region::LAC
- region::MENA
- region::NA
- region::SSA
## Review
If a study is a review, it will be captured under one of these tags.
- review::?
- review::critical
- review::integrative
- review::meta
- review::narrative
- review::scoping
- review::systematic
- review::umbrella
## Type
The primary type of intervention, circumstance or shock the study is interested in.
- type::automation
- type::cash_transfer
- type::child_labor
- type::collective_action
- type::cooperative_entrepreneurship
- type::counseling
- type::csr
- type::electrification
- type::experimental
- type::infrastructure
- type::institutional
- type::marketization
- type::maternity_benefit
- type::microcredit
- type::minimum_wage
- type::pension
- type::regulation
- type::rtw
- type::structural
- type::subsidy
- type::taxation
- type::trade_liberalization
- type::training
- type::ubi
- type::universal_licensing
- type::volunteering
- type::welfare
- type::work_programme
## Misc
- ⚠️ Invalid DOI
- ⛔ No DOI found
- favorite
- relevant
- integrated
- intersectional
- definition