Integrate improved paragraph spacing from feedback

This commit is contained in:
Marty Oehme 2022-09-08 17:17:47 +02:00
parent 4ddefcaaa6
commit 80194ddb03
Signed by: Marty
GPG Key ID: B7538B8F50A1C800
4 changed files with 41 additions and 6 deletions

View File

@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ a @WorldBank2022a report shows that 56% of children at late primary age in Benin
Looking purely at attendance rates, @McNabb2018 finds that the primary household-level determinants of attendance are the wealth of a household, its religion, as well as the education level of its household head.
Here, gender disparities persist, however,
with girls continuously less likely to attend and adopted girls being at the greatest disadvantage,
while boy tend to face higher opportunity costs than girls due to often working in the fields in which case the distance to a school begins to play an important role.
while boys tend to face higher opportunity costs than girls due to often working in the fields in which case the distance to a school begins to play an important role.
While the household-level variables do play a role ---
through the availability of educational resources at home, differences in schooling quality and overall health and well-being ---
@Gruijters2020 find that most of the disparity stems from the community-level:
@ -71,7 +71,8 @@ are the primary determinants, ahead even of access to a health facility in the c
Access to electricity in the country especially underlies a large heterogeneity based on location.
The overall level of electrification of Benin has been rising slowly ---
though outpacing population growth ---
from 22% in 2000 to 26% in 2005, 34% in 2010, a decline to 30% in 2015 and then a faster increase to 40% in 2019, altough a broad difference in electrification levels between urban (65%) and rural (17%) regions remain [@WorldBank2021].
from 22% in 2000 to 26% in 2005, 34% in 2010, a decline to 30% in 2015 and then a faster increase to 40% in 2019, although a broad difference in electrification levels between urban (65%) and rural (17%) regions remain [@WorldBank2021].
In rural areas there are generally three approaches to electrification that work outside of a connection to the main grid,
individual installation of solar panels or generators for smaller electric appliances,
collective solutions like kiosks offering electric charging for some cost,
@ -84,6 +85,7 @@ leaving behind households which are already neglected within the field of energy
The former, physical access, is argued by @Djossou2017 as well, emphasizing the need for continued infrastructure expansion to more households,
in order to provide access to more durable goods (fridges, mobile phones and internet) which can help decrease the inequality gap.
The latter, prohibitively high costs, should not be disregarded in such an infrastructure expansion as well, however.
One of the major obstacles to main grid connection remains the high charge a customer is expected to pay with solutions requiring continued political commitment to identify, examine and implement more low-cost electrification processes as well as financing solutions.
@Golumbeanu2013 point out the main obstacles that need to be addressed here:
the lack of incentives to increase electrical affordability,
@ -229,6 +231,7 @@ It also includes storage of energy to generate power (e.g. batteries) and projec
especially in rural areas.
For development aid to the electrification of Benin,
the monetary contributions are smaller but increasing and show trends quite different to that of overall development aid to the country.
The amount of overall development contributions to electrification increases from 2011 to 2020,
with significant increases in 2013 and 2015 for loans and 2019, 2020 for grants.
While there is a steady increase to the overall development aid toward electrification,

View File

@ -39,8 +39,9 @@ Furthermore, there is a significant spatial disparity between poverty rates.
with 45% of the country's poor residing in rural areas while 37% reside in the Balbala[^balbala] area [@Ibarra2020].
The study goes on to describe the high levels of deprivation for the rural poor, with the country's highest dependency ratios, lowest participation in the labor force, very low levels of employment in the households' heads and very low school enrollment,
and while urban poor face similar restrictions they have better access to public services and higher school attendance rates.
Acess to basic amenities and services in Djibouti is low (42.1%) and 15.5% of the population have no access to both electricity and sanitation,
Access to basic amenities and services in Djibouti is low (42.1%) and 15.5% of the population have no access to both electricity and sanitation,
and all people in monetary poverty are also deprived along multiple dimensions [@Mendiratta2020].
Over half the working-age population does not participate in the labor force with employment being estimated at 45% in 2017, lower than the 46.3% estimated for 1996, despite the country's economic growth [@Mendiratta2019].
@Emara2020 look at the overall impact of financial inclusion on poverty levels but find that,
first, Djibouti is way above its targeted poverty levels,
@ -56,6 +57,7 @@ More of its inequality hides in a large spatial and gendered heterogeneity.
Urban poor face high deprivation but higher access to public services and schooling compared to the rural poor,
who have only 41% access to improved water sources, 10% access to sanitation, 3% access to electricity,
and with only one third living close (under 1km) to a primary school [@Ibarra2020].
While in general over half the working-age population does not participate in the labor force,
the makeup is 59% of men and only 32% of women who participate,
mirroring unemployment rates with an estimated third of men and two thirds of women being unemployed [@Mendiratta2019].
@ -67,10 +69,12 @@ Nearly 41% of working-age women find themselves in positions of vulnerable emplo
Djibouti's economy is primarily, and within its formal sector almost exclusively, driven by its strategic location and possession of a deep-water port so it can act as a regional refueling, trading and transport shipment center [@WorldBank2022c].
At the same time, this interconnected economic nature and the country's heavy reliance on food and energy imports marks a key vulnerability and makes it immediately dependent on the stability of global trade and export markets,
a stability which was recently disrupted through a global pandemic [@WorldBank2022c].
Likewise, Djibouti depends on regional stability, since its economic growth is tightly coupled with the Ethiopian economy, sourcing around 70% of its port trade from this landlocked neighbor [@Mendiratta2019].
A series of droughts in the country threatened the livelihood of its nomadic and pastoralist population,
with many fleeing to neighboring countries, some becoming sedentary in village or city outskirts,
and the overall nomadic population decreasing by nearly three quarters from 2009 to 2017 [@Ibarra2020; @Mendiratta2019].
Additionally, during the early waves of Covid-19 Djibouti had one of the highest infection rates in the region,
and though it had a high recovery rate, it also had one of the highest fatality rates,
possibly due to deficiencies in its healthcare system [@ElKhamlichi2022].
@ -79,12 +83,13 @@ leaving a budget of 5% for health and 3% for social expenditures,
spendings which looks diminutive compared to its over 30% expenditures on public infrastructure [@WorldBank2022c].
Only 10% of rural poor inhabitants live close (under 1km) to a health facility [@Ibarra2020].
### Gender inequalities in livelihood opportunities
While still facing reduced rates of labor market participation, the country has expended effort on increasing women's opportunity for education:
Having overall lower literacy rates for women still,
the overall literacy rates in younger cohorts (10-24 years old) is significantly higher compared to older ones,
and the gaps have decreased from 24% difference between the genders (40-60 years old) to 10% (15-24 years old) and 2% (10-14 years old) [@Mendiratta2019].
### Gender inequalities in livelihood opportunities
Women's lower secondary completion rate grew from 28.6% in 2009 (compared to 35.2% men) to 56.3% in 2021 (54.0% for men) [@WorldBank2022d].
However, for 2017, women's upward educational mobility was still significantly worse than men's,
with non-poor men having an upward mobility of 53%, non-poor women 29%, poor men 19% and poor women only 10% against the national average of 36% [@Mendiratta2019].
@ -93,6 +98,7 @@ Such differences reflect themselves in firm ownership structures and on the labo
where 22.3% of all firms have female participation in ownership and only 14.2% a female top manager,
and both salaried employment and agricultural employment are male-dominated
(though agricultural work only with a slight and shrinking difference of 4%) [@WorldBank2022d].
Overall it seems, however, that past growth in the country's GDP is likely not favorable for an inclusive growth path,
with its large-scale infrastructure investments mostly creating demand for skilled workers
and neglect of social spending not allowing the buffers and social safety nets that prevent further drift into inequality.
@ -161,6 +167,7 @@ The amount of Official Development Assistance to Djibouti has generally been inc
first steadily and, since 2017, more rapidly, as can be seen in @fig-dji-aid-financetype.
With just under 150m USD in assistance contributions 2011 and just over 320m USD at its peak in 2020,
Djibouti has received less overall ODA funds than the other countries surveyed in this study.
The primary type of development assistance provided are grants, with loans making up between half and one third of the absolute grant amount in USD between 2011 and 2020.
Grants have trended slowly upwards from just over 100m USD in 2011 to 135m in 2014,
before fluctuating around this level until 2017,
@ -278,6 +285,7 @@ Source: Author's elaboration based on OECD ODA CRS (2022).
The sector-based breakdown of aid contributions for inclusive business growth in Djibouti can be seen in @tbl-dji-aid-projects.
It shows that overall development assistance to the necessary inclusive growth sectors in Djibouti is still small in absolute terms, especially for those in vulnerable positions.
The table is broken down into four sectors of development aid which drive the potential for inclusive growth in trade and business:
First, trade development encompasses trade policy and administrative management, trade facilitation, regional trade agreements, multilateral trade negotiations, trade-related adjustments and trade education and training.
Second, business growth is the combination of business policy and administrative management, privatization, business development services as well responsible business conduct ---
meaning the establishing of policy reform, implementation and enforcement of responsible business conduct, including, among others, implementation of guidelines for human rights support.

View File

@ -47,6 +47,7 @@ with an improvement in 2019/20 conversely being linked to favorable weather cond
with Western Ugandan households increasing in poverty while Northern and Eastern households reduced their share of households below the poverty line.
Additionally, they find that while transient poverty is more common than chronic poverty in Uganda,
nearly 10% of households continue to live in persistent material deprivation.
Lastly, for a long time it has been seen as an issue that Uganda puts its national poverty line too low with the line being put between 0.94 USD PPP and 1.07 USD PPP depending on the province (lower than the international live of 1.90 USD PPP),
while @vandeVen2021 estimate a living income of around 3.82 USD PPP would be required for a national poverty line that meets basic human rights for a decent living.
<!-- TODO find a source for the national poverty line being too low (quant data is already in vandeVen2021) -->
@ -57,6 +58,7 @@ inequality increases the size of the informal economy, as a large subsistence se
undermines the governments efforts to attain equitable income distributions in the economy and the creation of social safety nets for the poort, who, in turn,
have to turn to the informal economy to secure their livelihoods,
increasing its size both short- and long-term and feeding back into the cycle.
@Cali2014 finds that, already, one of the primary determinants of income disparity in more trade-exposed markets of Uganda in the 1990s were the increasing education differences leading to more disparate wage premiums.
Additionally, slow structural change ---
further impeded by the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, which pushed both urban and rural residents back into poverty ---
@ -64,6 +66,7 @@ leaves a low-productivity agricultural sector which becomes,
in combination with a lack of education, the strongest predictor of poverty:
the poverty rate in households with an uneducated household head (17% of all households) is 48% (2019/20),
while already households with a household head possessing primary education (also 17% of all) nearly cuts this in half with 25% poverty rate (2019/20) [@Atamanov2022].
The World Bank [-@WorldBank2022] calculated a Learning Poverty Indicator for Uganda which finds that 82% of children at late primary age are not proficient in reading, 81% of children do not achieve minimum proficiency level in reading at the end of primary schooling, and 4% of primary school-aged children are not enrolled in school at all.
@Datzberger2018 argues these problems primarily exist in Uganda due to choosing an approach to education that is primarily assimilation-based, that is, intended to effect change at the individual-level through fostering grassroots education throughout society at large,
instead of looking into more transformative policy approaches which would operate on a more systemic level,
@ -76,8 +79,10 @@ Such personal circumstances as access to a timely education play decisive role i
circumstances to which decent housing as well as access to clean water are equally fundamental building blocks [@Atamanov2022].
In 1990 a policy initiative to shift from a supply-driven to a demand-driven model for rural drinking water provision was enacted which, over time,
improved rural safe water coverage slightly but also made operation and maintenance of improved water sources pose a challenge that could impede long-term access to safe water.
In the country, access to improved water sources rose from 44% in 1990 to 60% in 2004 and 66% in 2010 [@Naiga2015].
In 2019, access to improved sources of drinking water in the country is at a level of 87% in urban areas and 74% in rural areas, with relatively little inequality in rural regions between poor and non-poor households [@Atamanov2022].
Health care facilities in rural areas are generally well connected to improved sources with 94% of facilities having access to public stand posts, protected spring technology, deep boreholes and some to rain harvesting tanks, gravity flow schemes or groundwater-based pumped piped water supplies [@Mulogo2018].
Thus, individual households are generally less well connected than health care facilities,
and rural households in turn less well than urban households.
@ -90,6 +95,7 @@ only 28% of households had access to improved water [@Mulogo2018].
and of the fewer existing improved water sources, only 53% were fully functional,
with 24% being only partly functional (having only low or intermittent yield) and 18% not being functional at all.
Additionally, they found blocked drainage channels in some of the sources which could in turn lead to a possible health risk due to contamination of the source.
@Naiga2018 argues that some reasons for the low access to working improved water sources is the absence of many of the organizational characteristics prescribed by the design principles of community-managed water infrastructure management ---
unclear social boundaries, missing collective-choice arrangements and a lack of sanctions or conflict resolution mechanisms ---
in other words, a policy failure resulting in lack of sufficient self-governance arrangements.
@ -102,6 +108,7 @@ Looking into the effects of climate change and its accompanying increase in clim
@Nagasha2019 find that it gender roles adapt while gender inequalities tend to increase,
with men participating more in firewood collection and water fetching but generally focused on assuming a single reproductive role while women played multiple roles simultaneously.
Two effects they found of this exacerbation were the women often being forced to engage their children in work activities to manage the simultaneous workload, and women, due to their exclusion from landownership in the region, being brought further into a state of dependence and thus made even more vulnerable to future climate change effects.
Water supply use seems to experience little change during emergency situations, and people's willingness (or ability) to pay for water is also too small to maintain water revenue without addressing the disparity in socio-economic attributes of households [@Sempewo2021; @Sempewo2021a].
Taken together, this hints at one possibility of subsequent health disparity increases due to prior income inequalities and poverty during emergency situations such as climate shocks.
@ -110,6 +117,7 @@ In Uganda, @Cooper2016 investigate the vulnerability of rural farmers to climate
many responses only protect against very specific events (45.4%) and most had no response at all to coping with rainfall variability:
while farmers with more land, education, access to government extensions and non-farm livelihoods have more capacity to buffer the shock,
both wealthier farmers (droughts as highest perceived risk) and poor farmers (extreme rainfall as highest) perceive themselves most vulnerable to rainfall-based events.
In the Isingiro district, @Twongyirwe2019 find that most farmers (68.6%) perceive food insecurity as a problem with the overwhelming majority seeing droughts as the major contributory issue to this food insecurity (95.6%).
They also find that mainly higher-income and larger farms see it as less of a problem,
while 13% of all farmers report that they did not, or could not, do anything to respond to the drought effects.
@ -125,6 +133,7 @@ the circumstances in neighboring refugee camps have more received more quantific
with only 67% of the Kyangwali refugee camp having access to improved water sources and only 46% access to sanitation service facilities [@Calderon-Villarreal2022].
Little access to sanitation sites can in turn negatively affect access to clean water if no improved water sources are nearby,
as was the case with a prolonged cholera outbreak in Kyangwali due to a contaminated stream in 2018 [@Monje2020].
Such resource scarcity can also be a gendered problem,
with predominantly girls and young women experiencing an increased amount of sexual and gender based violence as access to resources (especially water, food and firewood) becomes more scarce [@Logie2021].
In Nakivale refugee camp growing numbers of refugees have arrived throughout 2022,
@ -140,6 +149,7 @@ Thus, while Uganda's poverty and inequality are not trending towards drastically
hidden disparities bring its issues in focus once disaggregated:
Nationally, poverty is a looming transient affair for many households, more if increasing the country's very low national line of poverty.
Inequality derives itself partly from this poverty, making it necessary for many to accept informal work which, taken at large, in turn fosters further national inequality.
The role education plays in Uganda's allocation of poverty cannot be overstated, with especially many rural children not having adequate opportunity to access timely education.
This disparity could be exacerbated by poor quality access to clean water through improved water sources,
which in turn worsens food securities, retrenches gender role inequalities and precludes more children from their education.
@ -291,11 +301,12 @@ The breakdown of development aid to water supply infrastructure and education pr
It shows that overall the contributions to improve water access have been increasing, starting at 42.27m USD in 2011 and climbing to 146.43m USD by 2020.
The development funds are broken down into three categories:
Basic and large water supply improvement and education and training.
Education and training encompasses training for both professionals in the field itself and service providers.
Water supply improvement is broken down into funds for large systems ---
potable water treatment plants, intake works, large pumping stations and storage, as well as large-scale transmission and distribution systems ---
and more individual-level basic water supply,
such as handpumps, gravity wells, rainwater collection systems, storage tanks, and smaller, often shared, distributions systems,
such as handpumps, gravity wells, rainwater collection systems, storage tanks, and smaller, often shared, distributions systems.
The basic water supply encompasses a more endpoint-oriented collection of measures, often situated in rural locations.
Both the large and small scale categories encompass sanitation,
with larger-scale sewage pumping stations and trunk sewers, as well as smaller on-site disposal and sanitation systems, latrines and alternative systems.
@ -307,6 +318,7 @@ with little overall increase from 2011 to 2020.
Large-scale water supply and sanitation projects have, however, seen a significant increase over time, starting at a contribution of 17m USD in 2011 and receiving a 125.15m USD contribution in 2020.
This may speak to the necessity of larger infrastructure in place before more basic water supply infrastructure can make use of it,
or the provision of large infrastructure at the cost of implementations at smaller scales.
Education and training for water infrastructure management and service provision, while still receiving contributions of 14.53m USD and 12.40m USD in 2011 and 2012 respectively,
significantly decrease over the next years to amounts continuously under one million.
The monetary focus for aid provision thus lies on large-scale water supply and sanitation projects for these years.

View File

@ -24,6 +24,7 @@ On the other hand, Le et al. [-@Le2021] suggest a slight increase in overall inc
At the same time, the population groups most affected by poverty through welfare inequalities stay unaltered, as do largely the primary factors accompanying it:
There is severe poverty persistence among ethnic minorities in Vietnam [@Baulch2012],
concomitant with low education and skills, more prevalent dependency on subsistence agriculture, physical and social isolation, specific disadvantages which become linked to ethnic identities and a greater exposure to natural disasters and risks [@Kozel2014].
The country's overall estimated Gini coefficient for income fluctuates between 0.42 and 0.44 between 2010 and 2018, with the highest levels of income inequality observed in the Central Highlands in 2016,
though absolute income may be rising, with the top quintile having 9.2 times the income of the lowest quintile in 2010 and 9.8 times in 2016 [@Le2021].
For Gini coefficients estimated using consumption per capita, see @fig-vnm, which shows similar trends of increasing inequality, with 2010 constituting a significant increase.
@ -58,6 +59,7 @@ There are two complementary views on the primary dimensions of rural inequalitie
On the one hand, the urban-rural divide may be driven by structural effects:
the welfare returns to education and agricultural activities changed dramatically from,
and with it the requirements on policy adaptations required for stemming inequality.
Nguyen et al. [-@Nguyen2007] argue this for the period of 1993-1998, with their findings that income returns to education improved dramatically over this time and arguing through this that suggested development policies had a strictly urban bias ---
on the whole they would benefit both from better education and vastly benefit from the restructuring of Vietnam's economy.
This view was in turn confirmed when Theil Index decomposition found within-sector inequality remaining largely stable while between-sector inequality rose significantly [@Fesselmeyer2010].
@ -66,6 +68,7 @@ On the other, Thu Le and Booth [-@ThuLe2014] argue that the urban-rural inequali
The gap between urban and rural sectors grew, a gap which would continue to widen until 2002, when within-sector rural inequalities started to become more important for inequalities than those between the sectors [@Fritzen2005; @ThuLe2014].
In the time of within-sector inequality becoming more pronounced many studies, while important contributions to continued inequality research, had a tendency to mask those inequalities in favor of continued analysis of between-sector trends ---
often to the detriment of the high degree of heterogeneity depending on geographic characteristics such as remoteness or cultural factors, as Cao and Akita [-@Cao2008] note.
In a recent study, Bui and Imai [-@Bui2019] build on this earlier work,
and also find access to basic education the linchpin of improving rural welfare while its lack combined with economic restructuring precluded many from equal opportunities toward human capital improvement.
They find that, as within-sector became more pronounced again after 2010,
@ -74,6 +77,7 @@ Early income studies generally highlighted the important role of agricultural in
Benjamin et al. [-@Benjamin2017] expand on this over a longer time-frame by decomposing different household income sources underlying Vietnam's structural economic changes.
They find that, while there is an overall decrease in income inequality throughout Vietnam between 2002 and 2014 and the urban-rural divide also continued its downward trend,
rural inequality indeed increased over this time.
Wage income and family business income were the main drivers of overall inequality in 2002 (accounting for over 30% of income but 60% of inequality) and remittances add a small share on top,
which, while decreased in effect (risen to 42% of total income),
remain majorly correlated with income distributions and thus income inequality.
@ -99,6 +103,7 @@ a finding he suggests waws created due to environmental and structural differenc
Baulch et al. [-@Baulch2012] find that between 1993 and 2004, the welfare gap between ethnic minorities and the ethnic majority had increased by 14.6%, two-fifths of which were due to endowments such as demographic structure and education while geographic variables make up less than one-fifth.
They additionally suggest some drivers of the inequality being the lack of ability speaking the Vietnamese language or the distance to a commune or district center amplifying isolating effects, though a large part of the change was linked to temporal changes of unobservable factors -
which the study conjectures to be due to negative ethnic stereotyping, a poor understanding of ethnic customs and culture and further (unobserved) variations in household-level endowments.
While in 2002 the ethnic minority population living in rural areas was below 15%, it rose to over 18% in 2014 - both due to higher fertility among minorities and ethnic majority Kinh urbanizing at a higher rate - and the ratio of Kinh to minority incomes rose to more than 2.0 in 2014 [@Benjamin2017].
The same study finds that income inequality rose even more sharply *within* ethnic minorities, while that of rural Kinh, though increasing from 2002 to 2014, fell back to 2002 levels around 2014.
These findings suggest that the primary drivers of rural income inequality are a growing gap between Kinh and minorities while at the same time a similar rising inequality develops among minority rural populations themselves.
@ -117,8 +122,10 @@ In the same vein as the urban-rural divide, Nguyen et al. [-@Nguyen2007] thus ar
While the effect of agriculture on inequality outcomes is an equalizing one,
its future growth, and that of agricultural livelihoods, is threatened by vulnerability to risks such as natural disasters and environmental degradation, exacerbated through climate change [@Kozel2014].
Kozel [-@Kozel2014] goes on to argue the continuous precarity of poor households against economy-wide shocks (such as the effect of climate change on rainfall and temperatures) but also highlights the danger of vulnerable households *falling* into poverty through generated inequalities.
Looking at the particularities of flood risk management in the Ninh Binh province, Mottet and Roche [-@Mottet2009] find that most areas within the region are vulnerable.
They find the strengths of current management lying in prevention with existing dykes designed to channel high waters, effective monitoring of weather conditions (rainfall or typhoons) and consolidation or elevation of existing residences, while the weaknesses are mainly centered around insufficient information given to inhabitants over flood risks, few compensation systems for flood victims and construction policies continuing to allow building in flood-endangered zones.
Sen et al. [-@Sen2021] estimate that the main barriers to better information are farmers' lack of trust toward formal climate-related services, their lack of perceived risk from climate change itself and difficulties in balancing both climate adaptation and economic benefits of interventions.
They argue that, while ethnicity itself is not a barrier to information access with all farmers receiving information through informal channels ---
friends neighbors and market actors instead of agricultural departments or mass media ---
@ -137,6 +144,7 @@ The results are further intensification of inequality along existing social line
The effects of inequalities mainly affecting ethnic minorities are illustrated by Son and Kingsbury [-@Son2020],
with droughts impacting yield losses between 50% and 100%, cold snaps leading to loss of livestock and floods damaging residential structures but even more importantly disrupting livelihoods through landslides, crop destruction and overflowing fish ponds.
Locally employed coping strategies, they argue, are always conditional on the strength and foresight of institutions and implemented preventative policies along local but also regional and central levels.
Similarly, Ylipaa et al. [-@Ylipaa2019] analyze impacts mainly across the gender dimension to find that,
resulting inequalities may be exacerbated with differentiated rights and responsibilities leading to unequal opportunities and, especially, decreased female mobility in turn increasing their vulnerability to climate impacts with a reduced capacity to adapt.
Hudson et al. [-@Hudson2021] along the same dimension find that,
@ -147,6 +155,7 @@ While the quantitative evidence for impacts of such shock events are relatively
instead disaggregating the local and inter-sectoral effects to find out that flood protection efforts in the Mekong Delta often predominantly support large-scale farming while small-scale farmers can be harmed through them.
They find that measures decrease the aggregate total output and equity indicators by disaggregating profitability indicators into inundation, sedimentation, soil fertility, nutrient dynamics and behavioral land-use in an assessment which sees within-sector policy responses often having an effect on adjacent sectors,
increasing the inter-district Gini coefficient.
Adaptation during these catastrophic events reinforces the asset and endowment drivers of non-shock event times,
with impacts levels often depending on access to non-farm income sources, access to further arable land, knowledge of adaptive farming practices and mitigation of possible health risks such as water contamination [@Son2020].
Karpouzoglou et al. [-@Karpouzoglou2019] make the point that, ultimately, the pure coupling of flood resilience into infrastructural or institutional interventions needs to take care not to amplify existing inequalities through unforeseen consequences ('ripple effects') which can't be escaped by vulnerable people due to their existing immobility.
@ -160,6 +169,7 @@ its most precarious population.
Ethnic minorities' inequality is slowly increasing due to receiving worse returns to their existing assets (especially human capital and land) and generally worse access to endowments in the first place (land and educational infrastructure).
The restructuring of the economy, turning the labor force toward urban areas and within them wage work in manufacturing and service industries,
leaves behind immobile rural populations whose ability to be employed for non-farm shrink further.
All these factors are at risk of experiencing large negative shocks as climate change exacerbates existing extreme environmental conditions,
which in turn threaten to increase economic inequalities for both the rural population at large, ethnic minorities and women especially.
Women in rural areas experience worse mobility and fewer economic opportunities and are thus less able to adapt to environmental degradation.
@ -221,6 +231,7 @@ Decreasing continuously after 2014,
development assistance reached its lowest point of the last ten years in 2019 when it fell to just under 2.5bn USD,
before increasing slightly to just above 2.5bn USD in 2020.
Development aid to Vietnam is primarily driven by ODA loans instead of ODA grants.
While grants were just under 1bn USD in 2011 and decreased slightly over the following years to 600m USD in 2019,
decreasing loans were also the primary driver of the overall development aid contributions,
with the overall monetary curve closely following that of loan contributions.
@ -346,6 +357,7 @@ access to basic water supply saw significant increases to its contributions from
with 154m USD contributed at its peak in 2016 and shrinking drastically the following years to 39m USD in 2019,
its lowest contribution year.
Large water supply project contributions see a similar if less drastic curve, with contributions increasing from 105m USD in 2011 to 252m USD at their in 2018, before decreasing slightly over the next two years.
Thus, the contribution curves to basic and large-scale water supply projects somewhat follows the overall development aid contribution curve to Vietnam,
with peaks between 2016 and 2018 before more or less drastic drops in aid contributions.
Disaster risk reduction contributions, however, show the least similarity to the general trend,