From 6c14456d024993503bfa8daf1cb9f511bed05aa5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Marty Oehme Date: Tue, 30 Jan 2024 14:44:58 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] feat(notes): Add January meeting notes --- 03-documentation/meeting_2023-12-23.md | 6 +- 03-documentation/meeting_2024-01-26.md | 143 +++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 144 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) create mode 100644 03-documentation/meeting_2024-01-26.md diff --git a/03-documentation/meeting_2023-12-23.md b/03-documentation/meeting_2023-12-23.md index 99feacf..7ee98e2 100644 --- a/03-documentation/meeting_2023-12-23.md +++ b/03-documentation/meeting_2023-12-23.md @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ achieved: # Remaining issues - synthesis writing - remains very descriptive for the time being -- discussion - +- discussion - - in-text breakdowns exists but missing in tabular representation - still separated from qualitative grouping into more/less effective channels - appendix extraction - matrix structure? @@ -39,7 +39,3 @@ achieved: - for now mentioning them and have in tabular breakdown - the plan is that we hand in a draft report end of year now - but I still hand in my side as scoping review separately? - -# - - diff --git a/03-documentation/meeting_2024-01-26.md b/03-documentation/meeting_2024-01-26.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f4ee86f --- /dev/null +++ b/03-documentation/meeting_2024-01-26.md @@ -0,0 +1,143 @@ +# Meeting Miguel 2024-01-26 +achieved: + +- [ ] before end of year: + - hammered out a preliminary state of the art + - we have a synthesis that roughly follows our framework + + - 800 remaining to be screened/extracted + +- [ ] focus now: + - table reviewing main findings and strength of evidence + - screen the remaining 200 studies + - improve the writing on the synthesis itself + - to adhere a little closer to +- [ ] questions: + - large segment of 'model-only' studies, mostly from macroeconomics + - they do not form part of our main extracted sample pool + but I just refer to them + - logistical: + - create extraction matrices with main/statistical findings + - are we going to put those in the main Appendix? + or do we just pass on the CSV extraction as the data? + - is there a specific length I am going for for the end result? + - is it fine if for now I leave intro/conclusion more vague to fit in with rest of the document + - what we do not have anything on yet: + - ILO Convention recommendations + - Transition to the formal economy + - fair trade + +findings - channels - policy recc +gender inequality +- supply-side effects, esp maternal (family planning incentives; job protection; equal opportunity household carework) +- persistent discrimination and cultural views (strenghtening female agency, vicious circle of low FLFP and education) +- organisational disadvantagement in new economy (promoting female networking needs, self-promotion, managerial discretions) + +spatial inequality +- spatial component of non-spatial policies () + +## TODO + +- [ ] sort synthesis closer to framework +- [ ] create main findings table +- [ ] extract as much as possible +- create external (representativeness) / internal (strength of method) validity viz + +### Synthesis restructuring + +- employment creation + Whitworth2021 +- equal access to quality education & training +- worker protection + paid leave + Broadway2020 + Dustmann2012 + Davies2022 + unioniz + Cardinaleschi2019 + Dieckhoff2015 +- formalization + minimum wage laws + Chao2022 + Alinaghi2020 + Wong2019 + Gilbert2001 + Militaru2019 +- gender equality / non-discrimination + Clark2019 +- fair trade and development + Alexiou2023 + Ferguson2015 +- adequate social protection + Carstens2018 + SilveiraNeto2011 + Hardoy2015 + Mun2018 + Hojman2019 + +institutional + labour laws / regulatory systems + Broadway2020 + Dustmann2012 + Mun2018 + protective environmental policies + Davies2022 + Kuriyama2021 + Stock2021 + minimum wage laws + Chao2022 + Alinaghi2020 + Wong2019 + Gilbert2001 + SilveiraNeto2011 + Militaru2019 + collective bargaining + Alexiou2023 + Ferguson2015 + Cardinaleschi2019 + Dieckhoff2015 + Ahumada2023 + active labour market policies + Whitworth2021 + social protection laws/systems + Carstens2018 + Hardoy2015 + Clark2019 + Hojman2019 +structural + economic growth + Adams2015 + Xu2021 + Khan2021 + Liyanaarachchi2016 + Rendall2013 + Cieplinski2021 + fiscal policies + Shin2006 + Wang2020 + automation/technology + transport infrastructure + Blumenberg2014 + Adam2018 + informal economy + education access + Delesalle2021 + Pi2016 + Suh2017 + Coutinho2006 + Mukhopadhaya2003 + training? + Shepherd-Banigan2021 + Rosen2014 + Gates2000 + Poppen2017 + Thoresen2021 +agency + occupational segregation and social exclusion + Bailey2012 + Wang2016 + Standing2015 + Al-Mamun2014 + Emigh2018 + unconscious bias and discriminatory norms + Field2019